Bob Schatz
I remember an incident, almost five years ago, which for me was witnessing a development team’s descent into chaos. Stakeholders were asking for conflicting functions, and the incoming ideas from everywhere made the entire situation cacophonic. The team was completely lost and directionless. Until the moment someone proposed the astonishing concept of a proper product backlog. Everything changed within weeks. People unified. The team was able to focus on what objectives really had to be met.
Product Backlog Management: Best Practices & Examples
That scenario was an important lesson for me. A product backlog is not merely a configured list of tasks. It is a vital tool in the delivery of value, the interaction with stakeholders in scope expansion. I focus on passing the most useful insights I have on product backlogs, which immensely transform team workflows and the fundamental structure of working.
What is a Product Backlog?
A product is a developed backlog with a list of all the work that is captured from the product roadmap and is prioritised in order of priority. The development understands the importance of completing the most critical items in the roadmap, which is why it is placed at the top.
As per the Scrum Guide, the product backlog is a list of what is needed in order to enhance a product that is emergent and ordered. It is the only source of work that is done by the Scrum team. All the work that the team intends to do rests in a single place, which serves to eliminate confusion and provide clarity.
During Sprint Planning, items that can be completed within a Sprint and do not require additional explanation are said to be 'ready to pull'. When there's kanban capacity, members of the development team pull work from the product backlog, or during iterations in scrum, work is pulled in a batch.
Product Backlogs Characteristics
All work to be done is tracked in a single location, the product backlog. This eliminates the need to track work in several emails and spreadsheets.
Product backlog items are prioritised and ordered in a way that the items at the top return the highest value to the customers or the business. This ordering is a result of several strategic choices made on what is most "important" at that time.
As you learn about customer needs, technical constraints, and the ever-changing market conditions, the product backlog will change.
A single person is responsible and a single person is accountable for the content and ordering of the backlog. This prevents competing priorities from decision paralysis, and understanding Scrum Master vs Product Owner roles clarifies how they collaborate on backlog management.
Elements of a Product Backlog
Product Backlog Items
Features, functions, requirements, enhancements, and fixes are captured in product backlog items. Various forms are possible, including.
- User stories: Customer-oriented narrations such as, "As a customer, I wish to reset my password"
- Technical tasks: Reduction of technical infrastructure, architecture, and debt tasks
- Bugs and defects: Gaps that need to be fixed in order to improve overall quality
- Spikes: Limited scope research activities undertaken to mitigate uncertainty
- Improvements: Development of features to address customer concerns
Completeness in each item requires a description, acceptance criteria that indicate completion, and an estimate of the effort needed. Those closer to the top will be more in-depth.
Product Goal
The product goal envisions a state of the product that serves as a destination for the Product Scrum Team. It is situated in the product backlog and gives primary guidance for the distant future. The team must complete or drop one goal before taking another to prevent the team from spreading too thin.
Advantages of Having a Product Backlog that is Well-Written
A properly maintained status of the product backlog offers the following advantages:
- Better prioritisation. The most necessary tasks are done first. Teams dedicate time to the most relevant work as opposed to the most vocal.
- Achieving greater efficiency. Based on customer input and company goals, teams achieve maximum return on investment.
- More effective communication. All team members understand the goals and work toward the same goal. Stakeholders understand what is coming and when.
- Lower costs. Teams spend their time on work that has value. Resources are spent on things that customers actually want.
- Improved customer satisfaction. Team members, based on feedback, know what is wanted and deliver the needed features and functionality.
- Adaptability and flexibility. Any time priorities change, the backlog is available to assist teams in tackling change from the market without having to start fresh, demonstrating how Agile teams benefit from a Scrum Master who facilitates backlog refinement.
Creating your product backlog – step by step.
Step 1: Construct the Foundation of your Product Roadmap.
A product roadmap is a high-level plan that outlines the product vision, goals and objectives. To build one:
- Clearly define the product vision and mission
- Set key goals to achieve over the next 6 to 12 months
- Structure the goals into smaller themes
- Identify the major milestones and estimate rough timelines
Your roadmap is a guiding principle. The product backlog is the guiding principle.
Step 2: Populate the Backlog of Product Backlog Items with the Required Inputs
Start including new ideas gathered from inputs obtained after formulating your roadmap. These inputs are obtained from:
- Customer comments and ideas
- Technical and bug reports
- Stakeholders
- Analytics done in the market and competitors
When creating the item description, it should include:
- Explain in detail what is required.
- Explain the importance of the item (the impact it creates).
- Define the acceptance criteria and what it means to be done.
- Estimate the level of effort required.
- Identify what other tasks this item is dependent on.
Step 3: Coordination with the Team.
Holding sessions at frequent intervals according to a set schedule to discuss the vault is important. Sessions should focus on communicating the problems so that the issue is solved, and leveraging the best Scrum tools can enhance these collaborative sessions.
The goals of the sessions include:
- Cooperative discussion on future work.
- Answer each question with detail and thought.
- Identify the required procedures.
- Break the goals into mini-goals.
- Estimate the required work as a whole.
How to Economically Manage the Backlog of Products to be Used
Step 1: Determine the Customer Worth
How much a customer who is presented with a certain feature would benefit from it. Use different and varied sources:
- Talking to the customers and conducting surveys.
- Analysing the data surrounding certain features and how often they are engaged with.
- Tickets and requests are coming from customer support.
- Analyzing the competition.
It's important to note what the customer truly requires in order to properly set your priorities.
Step 2: Determine the Importance of the Feedback to be Received.
Focus on the items that add value quickly, earning actionable insights in return. Testing a feature at an early stage can save a lot of effort and time.
Step 3: Consider Implementation Complexity
When balancing a project portfolio, ensure each backlog includes a combination of quick wins along with more complex, longer-term projects. In what case, analyze each project's effort-to-impact ratio. Completing low-hanging fruit, e.g. low-effort, high-impact items, creates an atmosphere of momentum that enables progress on larger initiatives.
Step 4: Account for Dependencies
Who's on that task? Who will be responsible if that one is done and that one is missing? What must be done before people can do that? Dependencies are a type of constraint when it comes to prioritisation. To eliminate future bottlenecks, do the foundational work first.
Proven Prioritization Frameworks
| Framework | How It Works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| MoSCoW | Classifies as Must-have, Should-have, Could-have, and Won't-have. | Simple prioritization with stakeholders. |
| RICE Scoring | Assesses Reach, Impact, Confidence, and Effort. | Analytics-oriented teams. |
| Value vs Effort Matrix | Plots on a grid comparing value and effort. | Visual prioritization conversations. |
| Weighted Scoring | Assigns scores to criteria and computes total scores. | Complicated choices with many factors. |
Choose a framework that matches your team's stage of development and decision-making style, which are techniques emphasized in Scrum best practices.
Managing your Product Backlog over time.
1. Regular Backlog Refinement.
Product owners should lead backlog refinement every week or every two weeks. In the course of the refinement session, they:
- Add detail to a prioritized list of items that are about to enter the sprint
- Decompose larger items to derive smaller items
- Re-estimate effort using current information
- Delete outdated items
- Reorder items based on the current relevance of the items
Refinement makes sure that the bucket at the top of the backlog is always equipped with items ready for a sprint planning, and professionals enrolled in a CSM training course learn these refinement techniques as part of their certification journey.
2. Organizing Items by Timeframe
Defining user stories, estimations, and acceptance criteria is imperative for time-bound items (1-3 sprints) and involves full detail.
Requirements and estimations are rough for items with a medium time frame (3-6 months). The items are defined with basic requirements and are moderately detailed.
Items with a longer time frame (6+ months) are captured on a strategic level and can be kept abstract for now.
3. Handling Item Changes
Customer feedback and new requirements allow the product owner to change the order of work items. Changes to work items, once a set period is defined, should be set out minimally. This is to avoid distractions from the team's goal.
Actions This Guide Is Slated To Prevent
The product owner is not obligated to keep the focus of the team's work on the project. After the project begins, feedback is incorporated rather than adjusting priorities.
The team limits the work of the project to the aspects visible to the customer. These items are alongside and project the technical work that is capable of attracting debt, as well as the development of the needed framework.
The focus of the work is not visible to the team. Shared work tools are not utilized, and members of the team can not see the current priorities.
Product Backlog vs Sprint Backlog
| Product Backlog | Sprint Backlog | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | All possible work relating to the product | Committed to working for one sprint |
| Timeframe | Evolving, in current and continuous work | Set for one to four weeks |
| Owner | Product owner | Development team |
| Changes | Anytime | Set once the sprint begins |
| Purpose | Strategic | Execution |
The sprint begins from the planned work and for the product backlog, focusing on the sprint backlog. The team is then able to pick the items that are of the greatest importance for that sprint from the product backlog, demonstrating key Scrum Master roles and responsibilities in facilitating this process.
Best Practices for Success
- Keep a single backlog. Eliminate siloed work. One backlog improves visibility.
- Refine on a cadence. Set systematic refinement sessions to stop backlogs from becoming dumping grounds.
- Value varied input. Developers, designers, and other stakeholders should contribute to discussions.
- Acceptance criteria must be specific. Each work item must have clear and unambiguous criteria for thresholding "done."
- Quick wins and strategic work should be blended. Both are important to sustain and generate further advances towards larger objectives.
- Value should drive all efforts. Always ask, "What are the reasons behind this for the customers?"
Conclusion
Product backlogs change the way teams deliver value by clarifying the order of importance and helping avoid the effort on the work that matters the most to optimize everyone's effort. Begin with a well-articulated product vision. Focus on the most valuable first. Refine on a cadence and watch the clutter and focus to yield effectiveness increase. For professionals looking to master these techniques, enrolling in a comprehensive CSM training program provides structured guidance on backlog management and agile principles, and understanding CSM certification requirements helps you plan your certification journey. Additionally, evaluating CSM vs CSPO certifications can help you determine which role aligns best with your career aspirations.
Bob Schatz is a leader in implementing Agile development techniques such as Scrum and XP. His expertise includes Scrum Training, Agile Development, Process Improvement Techniques, Visioning & Goal Setting, Leadership Coaching/Training, Team Coaching, Conflict Resolution, Organisational Cultural Change, Agile Project Project Management and Agile Portfolio Management among many others.
Questions people ask
Published